Anonymous Google Reviews? 🤔
As you might have heard, Google is reintroducing anonymous reviews. They deprecated this feature in 2018, and now…
Some industries would benefit enormously from a feature like this—such as therapists or doctors—where people are more sensitive about being exposed publicly when identifying themselves as patients.
However, there are also downsides to anonymous Google reviews, such as the concern that this feature could be abused for fake reviews and attacks.
However, here is the truth about anonymous Google reviews.
Google is not actually enabling you to leave anonymous Google reviews. There is no such thing as anonymous Google reviews.
All Google did was add a feature that lets you add a nickname to your Google account.
This is what the announcement on Google's blog said:
If you prefer not to use your real name, you can now choose a nickname and profile picture to be associated with your reviews — so you can give that helpful shop a five-star review as “Eager Elf” or “Julia Loves Sweets.”
Source: Simplify the holidays with 4 new Google Maps features
I thought ok cool, let's try it.
So I've tried and here is what I found:
Google provides instructions on how to do it. However, depending on who you ask—Gemini or the Google Business Profile Help Center, you’ll get two different versions. There’s no box to tick for “Use custom display name & picture posting.”
If you want to fin dit, you’ll need to go to the profile section and find the name field. More detailed instructions on how to find the nickname section are below.
When you go to your Google account and navigate to the nickname section, you can choose from three different types of nicknames.
However, none of them excludes your real name. This only lets you add a nickname alongside your existing name, it doesn’t let you use the nickname only.
“This is confusing,” I thought. “Where’s the option to replace my real name with a nickname?” Well, there is no option.
Here’s what Google offers you. I added “TK” as my nickname.
None of these options makes my account anonymous by adding the nickname.
You can see, Google says "Display name as" - and this is exactly how the name is displayed after you add a nickname.
It shows my name, including the nickname—not really the result I was hoping for.
Now, if you want to turn your Google account into an anonymous account to leave anonymous Google reviews, you’d need to change your real name. However, that will show your changed name on every review you’ve ever left, not just the ones you’d like to be anonymous for.
You might as well open a totally new Google account to leave an anonymous review, this “new” feature won’t help you either way.
How to add a nickname to your Google Profile
If you want to add a nickname to your Google account and post anonymous Google reviews, here is a step by step guide.
1. Visit your Google profile by clicking on your profile picture at the top right
2. Click "Manage Googel account"
3. Hit "Personal Info"
4. Click on the "Name" cell
5. Click on "Display name as"
6. Change the nickname and hit "save"
This is how you can enable your profile to leave anonymous Google reviews. At least if you change your real name on the account. Which doesn't need a nickname option as trhis has been around since day one.
Here is my personal evaluation about leaving anonymous Google reviews
Let's have a look at the pros and cons of this change and what other thoughts could play a role.
Here are a few pros:
1. Businesses in sensitive industries can finally get reviews without their clients/patients/customers fearing public exposure for seeking a specific service. (like psychotherapists, psychologists, brothels, or any other sensitive niche)
2. People can now more freely leave their negative feedback in general. Especially in smaller towns and communities where your reputation is your net worth it's much harder to leave negative reviews.
Here are the cons:
1. This will most likely lead to more unfair reviews from legitimate accounts. People don't need to be that thorough anymore as their personal reputation is not at stake anymore. It makes it easier to add false claims.
2. It's getting harder for businesses to prove that a reviewer is not an actual customer. I know that this is actually being used by Google as one of the reviews I left was reported to Google and Google asked me if I can prove that I did business with that company because the company said they have no recollection of who I am. Google said they will keep the review if I can prove it. I could prove it by sending an invoice and email screenshots with the result that the review remained active.
3. This will push illegitimate reviews. People who are real but are not allowed to leave reviews like ex-employees, competitors, and other people who have an interest in hurting the business's reputation. These people can now freely leave fake reviews without needing to fear any consequences. Plus, those legitimate accounts are much stronger than new fake profiles, which means the reviews will usually stick. Especially if the reviewer only leaves a rating.
If you ask me, this system is suboptimal and will inevitably lead to more problems for businesses. The only way to fix this is if the businesses could make this feature optional on their profiles so that therapists and co could just turn it on and everyone who doesn't like it can turn it off. That would be great and an actual improvement.
Conclusion
The anonymous Google review feature is misleading. Google says the new feature is enabling you to leave a review under a different name. Which is simply not true. Adding a nickname to your real Google name doesn't allow you to hide your real name, it just adds it.
This is why I think the feature is overrated as it has always been possible to change your real Google account name and post anonymously through a made up name. You can see this happening everywhere already. Some people post through a fake name, other use their real one.
What's your take? Are you going to use this feature?